
- Producer's Note
- Full Track Listing
- Cover Art
MusicWeb International Review
A tremendous reading - fluctuating, brimming, teeming with ardent lyricism, and a fulsome example of Beecham’s art
REVIEW OF VOLUME 2
The second in the series of Blue Network concerts in New York on 14 April 1945 (see Volume 1
for further details) saw a tribute concert in memory of President
Roosevelt who had died just two days before. The programme had to be
changed to reflect the sombre nature of the occasion which was
interrupted for a funeral report from the White House. A few salient
details need to be borne in mind. After the introduction by Milton Cross
there was a minute’s silence – one can hear cross-station interference –
that producer
Almost
everything here is familiar from Beecham’s extant discography, though
not everything will be familiar from on-the-wing live performances such
as these. Siegfried’s Funeral March starts slightly awkwardly and
ensemble is less blended than in his 1953 RPO studio performance.
Nevertheless, the cumulative charge of the music-making is very strong
indeed. Something should be said about Pristine’s tracking details which
list track 3 as The Death of Mélisande from Sibelius’s Op.46 suite. In fact, there are, to be precise, three movements from the suite; Mélisande (No.2), Pastorale (No.5) and finally, and most appropriately, The Death of Mélisande
itself. This offers a more wide-ranging mini-suite in which playful
arabesques lighten the commemorative and grieving elements enshrined in
the bulk of Beecham’s programme. His 1955 RPO performance may be more
tightly played but this New York one has great gravity – his vocal
exhortations during this last tableau will be familiar to those who know
his similarly live BBC Second Symphony recording. The inclusion of the
Adagio from Mozart’s Divertimento in D, K131, is apt.
The surface hiss level is at its most intrusive in the second movement of Schubert’s Unfinished.
But the brass is trenchant and the strings taut and memories will stir
of his pre-war reading with the LPO just as much as the 1951 RPO. By a
quirk of reportage therefore, given that the concert relay is halted
before the end of the work, we have a doubly-unfinished symphony. The
real bonus for Beecham aficionados is the inclusion of Tchaikovsky’s Elegie from the Serenade for Strings, which he never recorded commercially. Milton Cross announces this as Berlioz’s Intermezzo and Serenade,
a clue perhaps to the original concert line-up. This is a tremendous
reading - fluctuating, brimming, teeming with ardent lyricism, and a
fulsome example of Beecham’s art. The concert ends with the Marche Troyenne - a noble way in which to end this near-hour long salute to the departed leader.
This sequence of continuing discs leads me to hope that aural evidence
has survived of Beecham’s coast-to-coast tour of the US with the RPO in
1950.
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb International